![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
"Utopia"
Oh.My.God. What a fabulous episode it was. I think the best of the 3 season and really not just because Jack’s back (really *g*).
I loved the initial tension between Jack and the Doctor. And I think it was fantastic idea, to make the Doctor deliberately left Jack behind. I know that some people think it’s cruel and OC for Doctor, but I think it actually fits the character perfectly. We know the Doctor can be ruthless at times, we saw it with both of them (can’t say about the classic series, because I don’t know it). But it’s only when he thinks it’s absolutely necessary. He’s not human, after all. And although he often acts like one, he’s got his own moral code and sticks to it.
I think Jack understands him better than anyone (maybe because he was born in 51 century, maybe because of what he’s been through). The scene in radiation chamber was one of the best of all three seasons. And it’s so true what RTD said in “Confidential” – to make men talk, they need to be in a life threatening situation, with a ticking clock and door between them. It was just brilliant and I doubt it would have work if they talked in any other circumstances. And the look the Doctor and Jack exchanged at the end of it, was the best closing "line" possible.
Now, it was pretty clear, that Martha was mostly a “wallpaper” through most of the episode. I wish I could feel for her, but really can’t. It’s almost the end of the season and through all of it, I was trying to give her the benefit of the doubt. I actually liked her in the first ep, and in few other moments. But I think she’s way to clingy and dependable, when it comes to the Doctor. All this "unrequited love" theme makes me itchy. I know I shouldn’t compare her to Rose, but that’s another thing I can’t stop doing.
How will they get out?
Will Jack be able to return to Earth in Tardis (assuming they get it back), if it react so violently in his presence? And will he able to ever travel with the Doctor again?
Is everything between Jack and Doctor cleared up?
It's not as coherent as I wish it was, but I'm still sick and on pretty strong drugs. Add a good portion of exctitement, and that's what you get... ;-)
I think I'll go watch it again, just to make sure I have proper (ekhem...) dreams tonight.